Showing posts with label chiropractors. Show all posts
Showing posts with label chiropractors. Show all posts

Saturday, March 14, 2009

Chiropractor calls me a "hater"

I enjoy scientific debates, and if I'm wrong I'll happily change my mind. As a scientist, there's no shame at all in changing your mind when new evidence comes along. However, I would have expected better from a chiropractor than the argument below, also on the web here: http://www.spinewave.co.nz/media/News__Reviews___March_2009.pdf

Forget the ad hominem stuff, that I'm a hater and .....young and foriegn! And the fact that he calls himself a doctor, but not me. The arguments are particularly poor and hardly worth destroying....but I'll do it anyway.

1. The results of a political commission are not strong scientific evidence - a small RCT provides better evidence and systematic reviews provide way better evidence.

2. Even if the 1979 committee actually got it right at the time, the conclusions may well no longer be valid 30 years later. In the 1960's it was thought that thalidomide was a really good drug for pregnant women. In  1979 we didn't know a fraction as much as we do now about evidence-based medicine. In the early 1990's, we thought that bed rest was the best thing for back pain, now we think exactly the opposite. A couple of years ago we thought that cox-2 inhibitors were good painkillers with less side effects, now we think they probably cause a lot of heart attacks.

Here is the article in full:

Commission of Inquiry into Chiropractic

The Buddha said man's greatest sin is his ignorance. Jesus said forgive them, for they know not what they do. In light of what's gone down recently on the TV1 Breakfast Show between chiropractic and medicine, I decided it was time to return to the Bible: "Chiropractic in New Zealand", the government's Royal Commission of Inquiry into Chiropractic, 1979. 

What an amazing document. As a student one never reads past page 5, the summary, because we believe in what we do as chiropractors, see incredible results with people, and leave college under the illusion that the world is waiting with open arms for the gift that is chiropractic. Sadly not so. As they say on MTV Cribs, there are Haters. They hate the Game... and the Player. People who won't even make eye contact with you because you're a chiropractor. And the ugliness of this world continually rears its head as new Haters emerge thinking none of this has been investigated before; they're the first to walk the Earth as God's gift to medicine. Point in case: Shaun Holt, Medical Researcher on TV1 Breakfast (watch it here<http://tvnz.co.nz/breakfast-news/breakfast-monday-march-09-2525390/video?vid=2525815>). A young man, foreign, and clearly still in diapers when this Royal Commission took place in 1979.

 Is chiropractic safe? Should chiropractors be called doctors? What can chiropractors "treat"? Should chiropractors be in hospitals? All these questions have already been answered! Why I am going to highlight this document every month from now is because its poignant, relevant, and important that the public understands chiropractic for what it is: A well grounded, scientific healing art that is safe.

 "In July 1976, the then Minister of Health announced the Government's decision to establish a Commission of Inquiry into Chiropractic" (p.6). Organisations with legal representation appeared from every faction: ACC, Crown Law Office, Health Dept., GP Society, NZ Associations of Osteopaths, Nurses, Physiotherapists, Medicine, Chiropractic and the Social Welfare Dept. There were hundreds of submissions and thousands of petitioners. "This report follows an extended inquiry which developed into probably the most comprehensive and detailed independent examination of chiropractic ever undertaken in any country" (p.1). This is the document the entire world now looks to when chiropractic is considered legally. All the barristers, lawyers and Governor-General thought this inquiry would only take two months. It took over two years to collate all the information because of the sheer depth that chiropractic has to offer - and they wanted to do it right. One of the many reasons the Commission was set up was because organised medicine was "adamantly opposed" to chiropractic gaining recognition in health care in NZ. What's changed? Before the ad break TV1 plays across the screen, CHIROPRACTIC UNDER SCRUTINY. And then the next day plays, CHIROPRACTORS FIGHT BACK. It's complete and utter media hype, which does nothing but denigrate the profession based largely on - and I speculate - one miscreant's simple opinion.

 To conclude this month's instalment, the Governor-General stated that "by the end of the inquiry we found ourselves irresistibly and with complete unanimity drawn to the conclusion that modern chiropractic is a soundly-based and valuable branch of health care in a specialised area neglected by the medical profession" (p.2). "In the face of evidence it is unreasonable for the medical establishment to maintain its attitude of hostility towards chiropractors" (p.252)

 Reference: Hasselberg, P. D., Chiropractic in New Zealand: Report of the Commission of Inquiry. Government Printer. 1979. Wellington, NZ.

 Dr Neil Bossenger

CHIROPRACTOR



Monday, March 9, 2009

A chiropractor responds....

Breakfast TV had a chiropractor on to reply. Here's the video, followed by my responses.





1. ...based on two premises: body can heal itself and the nervous system controls the body

My response: Yes, but these premises do not demonstrate that chiropracty works


2. chiropracty...not based on this belief that energy flows....

My response: Yes it is, it is the basic underlying premise! Search the internet and you will find hundreds of examples eg. http://www.chirohealth.org/pdf/WantEnergy.pdf. Daniel Palmer, the founder of chiropracty developed a theory of "innate intelligence", which acts as the "body's guiding energy", with blockages leading to disease.


3. not every asthma case is going to respond to adjusting

My response: Implies that it works for some patients. No it doesn't
http://jrsm.rsmjournals.com/cgi/content/abstract/99/4/192


4. he didn't say where (700 cases of severe problems) came from

My response: Of course I did not list of all the references in a 4 minute live TV interview. I referred to my paper last year and the Andrew Gilbey survey - a google search would quickly find my sources and they are on my previous blog post.


5. risk of stroke 1 in 5.8 million

My response: Cherry-picking of the data - the range in the literature is from 1 in 100,000 to 1 in 5.8 million. See http://www.library.nhs.uk/cam/ViewResource.aspx?resID=269229&tabID=289&catID=10844 for more info and the references.


6. risk of stroke same from a chiropractor as a GP

My response: This is the study, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18204390. It has been widely discredited, see here for a good summary http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=362 and here for another http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=170


7. chiropractors safest for spine adjustments

My response: Yes, this is probably true, but not the point. The point is whether spine adjustments are beneficial


8. 100-200,000 admissions to hospital in USA each year due to painkillers

My response: I can not find any papers to back this up, however, I'll happily concede that anti-inflammatory drugs can cause gastric bleeding and other side effects. It seems very high though and would mean that 1 in every 200 admissions was due to a reaction to painkillers. I doubt it. However, this is part of the risk/benefit considerations for any treatment and does not change my overall comments: chiropractors may be OK for bad backs, but nothing else; there are many reports of severe adverse effects from chiropractic neck manipulation; many chiropractors claim to be able to treat non-musculoskeletal diseases when the evidence shows they clearly can not; many chiropractors call themselves doctor, which is misleading, if not illegal. 



Sunday, March 8, 2009

Breakfast TV: Chiropractors

This was my interview on chiropractors on Breakfast TV today.




Here are links where you can verify some of my comments:

A systematic review of systematic reviews of spinal manipulation
http://jrsm.rsmjournals.com/cgi/content/abstract/99/4/192


Chiropractic Class Action
http://albertachiroclassaction.ca/


Use of inappropriate titles by New Zealand practitioners of acupuncture, chiropractic, and osteopathy
http://www.nzma.org.nz/journal/abstract.php?id=3160


Chiropractic manipulation and stroke
http://stroke.ahajournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/strokeaha;32/5/1054


Stroke following chiropractic manipulation of the cervical spine
http://www.springerlink.com/content/gyvw3wralxb15van/

I am keen to receive any feedback, positive or negative