Showing posts with label medical devices. Show all posts
Showing posts with label medical devices. Show all posts

Sunday, January 2, 2011

510(k) Approval Timeline Part 2

My original 510(k) approval timeline is my post popular post ever!  I didn't even follow up with my latest project information.  We extended the disposable product line and it was 30 day FDA review, no questions asked / response required, approval in April to May 2010.  We justified not doing sterilization, biocompatibilty, shelf life, and packaging.  All in all it was about as good as it can get time wise.  Timeline went something like this:

  • August to December 2009: Concept and prototype to design

  • Jan to March 2010: Product build and verification / validation testing

  • April to May 2010: 510(k) Approval

Our validation was an animal study using a physician, who filled out a questionnaire like one to ten, how much is this better than the predicate device after he or she used it, oh boy did I learn something there, I'll go over that some other time.



Now we just have to sell them...



Friday, November 26, 2010

The Attribute Gage R&R

There is not that much information about the attribute gage (gauge) R&R readily available online (that I was able to find), so I thought I'd cover what I've done.  First the basics, an attribute is something you can't quantify, generally a visual inspection- is this part "red" or something like that.  While it generally seems simple, especially to the technical leads, operators can often get tripped up trying to pass or fail parts based on a description or a couple pictures.  In the red example, can operators compare against the Pantone effectively and is this repeatable?  You want to have your acceptance criteria and how you are proposing to test it with trained operators set up beforehand.



Your gage R&R should mimic what you do on the line and should be set up that way.  If the operator does an inspection on the attribute before passing the part, then a final QC does that same inspection, you have two inspections and this should be part of your testing.  You should present this as the entire package when possible.  QA types tend to freak out when they hear you would accept a 10% possibility of passing a bad part, when in reality its 0.1%.  Having the two (or more) inspections will be really helpful when you get to the acceptance criteria portion.



Test Method: You need to determine the number of operators, parts and trials.  Trials is easy, just use three, everyone does, obviously more is better, but three is generally good enough and you don't want to be looking at parts all day.  For operators, you need two, but if you have three or more lines or shifts, you can include those easily enough.  The number of parts is where it gets tricky and you're going to have to make a judgment call.  Generally medical device companies rely on some sort of confidence and reliability based on the severity or RPN of the potential failure, however, in the case of gage R&R everyone seems to follow auto industry guidelines which are usually a smaller quantity, 30 is generally defensible either way.



The Acceptance Criteria:  The key one medical device companies are concerned with is the probability of a miss, which is defined as:

  • Probability of a Miss = (# times a bad part was passed) / (# of opportunities) [i.e. number of inspections]

You need to base this on what is acceptable and preferably tie this back into your risk analysis (you may have to increase sample size).  The good news is, if you're doing two of the same inspection, you can set it up so that your acceptance criteria can be something like:

  • Probability of a Miss (2 inspections) = (# of times a miss by one operator that were missed by another operator) / (# of opportunities)

In that way you can argue that different types of misses will be caught by different operators, but you are only concerned with the fact that it is caught at some point in the process.  Setting it up this way significantly lowers the likelihood of a miss and allows you some flexibility.



Other Information:  I recommend keeping it simple and only requiring a certain probability of a miss in your protocol (maybe effectiveness as well).  You'll want the rest of the information you can collect documented, but that is a business decision, not a safety decision.  You can cover:

  1. Effectiveness - (# of parts correctly identified) / (# of opportunities) [a low effectiveness indicates your process is probably not robust and will give you trouble over time, greater than 70% is generally acceptable]

  2. Probability of a false alarm = (# times a good part was rejected) / (# of opportunities) [waste]

  3. Repeatability = (# agreements) / (# parts inspected) [calculate per operator and total, if an operator has low repeatability, less than 80% or so, he or she needs retrained]

  4. Reproducibility = (# agreements among all operators) / (# parts inspected)

  5. Bias = (Probability of a false alarm) / (Probability of a miss) [calculate per operator and total]



The Test Setup:  For this you'll need two experts in the attribute being inspected, the experts will sort out the good parts from the bad, label them in some fashion, and randomize them.  In my experience you should have at least 25% bad parts, even though your process isn't likely to have 25% reject rate (hopefully).  It is nice to include some very marginal parts, but those can be hard to find and agree on.  Don't have the operators performing the test make the parts if you can avoid it.



The Test:  You want to set it up so an operator makes a determination and someone else records it, don't let the operators know the sample being given to them, previous results, or talk amongst themselves.  Do the testing on the line and try to keep the production pace.  During a gage R&R I find the operators tend to err on the cautious side.



The Results:  There you go, you can now say your test method is qualified and have the data to back it up.  You can also make operator decisions based on the results, maybe move one around to catch things earlier in the process, which one is the go to person, etc.  I find the attribute gage R&R easier to perform than the variable one, yet it is generally more important than a dimensional one from a safety perspective because there are more things I can't measure easily.

Enhanced by Zemanta



Wednesday, July 7, 2010

510(k) Infographic

I tried my hand at making an infographic full of 510(k) information.  Well I really only collected the facts and let a graphic designer do the rest, he fixed up some stuff from yesterday so I'm happy.  Click to enlarge!




Tuesday, May 5, 2009

Non conforming materials

Dealing with non conforming materials has become a more time consuming part of my job recently and a topic of debate within the company. The FDA has 21 CFR 820.90 on non conforming product which says:
"(a)Control of nonconforming product. Each manufacturer shall establish and maintain procedures to control product that does not conform to specified requirements. The procedures shall address the identification, documentation, evaluation, segregation, and disposition of nonconforming product. The evaluation of nonconformance shall include a determination of the need for an investigation and notification of the persons or organizations responsible for the nonconformance. The evaluation and any investigation shall be documented."
The FDA's definition of product in this case includes components and material. This has been interpreted by many as every nonconformance requires a full on investigation into the root cause and a corrective action, pictures, documentation changes and the whole deal. In fact, some have argued that each non conformance needs a CAPA that must be closed before the material can move on to the next stage. That is all fine and good unless you want to make money, lets be realistic here.

Besides, as a startup most of the corrective actions don't necessarily get too far. Lets say I get one custom cable out of 20 with a bad crimp that gives an intermittant signal. The signal is checked as it leaves the vendor, but since it was intermittant it wasn't caught. The conversation goes something like this:

Me: One of your cables had a bad crimp and the signal was intermittant.
Vendor: We're sorry, we check them 100% before they are sent out, return the cable and we will credit your account the $28 the cable cost or just recrimp it yourself.
Me: Okay.

I admit that getting after vendors isn't one of my strong points (isn't that for purchasing?), but we need these guys more than they need us- I don't want to source another vendor and then wait for their lead time to get more parts. Now if the cable is miswired or the part tolerance is too tight, then I'll fix the drawing, but our device has many parts and from time to time you're going to run into one off problems that shouldn't require huge amounts of wasted effort.

On the other end of the spectrum, I do know that the FDA will write you up if you just scrap every non conformance below a certain dollar value without explanation or investigation, so that is out of the question. So far I've been unable to convince people to include routine rework in the manufacturing process, this will be fine until nothing gets done because everything is waiting on evaluation and disposition then we will change. The best solution seems to be to link non-conformances with a risk analysis, then spend the majority of your time on the ones that could lead to patient risk or entire lots of incoming material being bad. At least that way I don't spend two hours on four dirty $2 boxes.



Monday, March 9, 2009

Misconceptions on medical device costs

The Happy Hospitalist has a post on a vacuum assisted wound closure device, Wound VAC, his post and the Wound Vac site have videos and everything. Anyway, Happy complains about the cost:

"I checked with Happy's Hospital wound care nurse. Guess how much these cost retail, should you wish to purchase them outright?

...

Nope. She tells me to buy them outright is thirty thousand dollars. Thirty grand for a LCD screen and some surgical steel, surrounded by a power supply.

I suspect parts and manufacturing would run you about $300. Legal costs about $29,700."

No one pays retail anyway! I think those numbers are a bit off, since you can't buy a lab vacuum pump for less than $1000, let alone an easily portable one with a color touch screen, battery, alarm system, controller and medical grade power supply, I would guess the cost of goods is more likely around $4000. It is tough to say since I don't know what exactly is included in a system. Medical device assembly is not as cheap as you think it is, traceability requirements tend to drive up costs, plus it is difficult to outsource. This isn't consumer electronics where you can just throw it together and hope it works.

There are some legal costs, but I bet they're not more than $100 per device. Although I'm obviously not an expert. What you're mostly paying for is meeting regulations and the design and validation of the next wound care device. Those alarms don't write and validate themselves.