Showing posts with label paperwork. Show all posts
Showing posts with label paperwork. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

The perception of risky process changes

Now that we have an approved device we're spending at least some time on process improvement instead of all out research and development. Unfortunately, even though everything is fairly new some of it is already difficult to change.

We have a piece of test equipment that displays pass or fail, prints out a page of results, and writes them to a database. The operator runs the test, marks pass or fail in the traveler, then staples the results to it. During a sort of related process change I suggested we take out the print out of the results. This was met with quite the uproar and doubt about how we could ever do it.

Apparently removing a redundant step that no one ever looked at was a big deal. Engineering and complaints thought it might be useful, even though they never used the printouts two years in- but someday they might. The change would save some minimal amount of money on supplies, transferring of materials into and out of the clean room and storage, along with associated labor. I was able to finally make headway when I pointed out that we do plenty of visual inspections that do not have another record and in this case we still had a record in the database. Everyone initially thought it sounded like a risky change based and we could be out of compliance, but it was all our own perception.

While this isn't the most impactful example, I think I may have learned the value of taking time up front to set this all up efficiently, but I'm not sure I'll be able to convince anyone to add extra time for these activities the next time around. "We can take care of that stuff during validation!"



Sunday, April 25, 2010

Annual review of received parts' dimensions

Many companies perform an annual review of every dimension or 100% inspection on all received parts. While this may serve as a halfway decent preventive action, I'm not convinced it is worth it. If you have automated inspection methods, maybe then it is not too much effort, but we're still using hand tools or manual adjustments for the majority of our parts.

You could argue that you have a critical device, we have to check for dimension drift. Well why aren't you checking for that anyway? And if it is so critical shouldn't you have insured that the supplier's process was capable before you even signed up with them? If it is truly critical and you're not checking it but once a year, good luck with that.

Additionally, if you do find something out of specification, nine times out of ten it is going to be on a non-critical dimension, or else you would have caught it in receiving inspection or manufacturing anyway. Once you find the out of spec item, you have to go back to your inventory, check it, then justify why it is either okay and change the specification, or send it back, and jump through hoops to justify why it was okay to use on the ones sold, but not okay to use going forward, or whatever other contortions QA wants.

In my experience these generally boil down to unclear or unnecessary specifications or measurement issues, where to start measuring a curve, a hole over specified, etc. Another argument for doing it right the first time and checking your supplier's process.

However, this if often a difficult battle, as new parts are generally part of R&D efforts and the team from R&D is behind schedule and they always try to make up schedule time by trying to get either quality or manufacturing to compromise on one issue or another (I *may* have pointed this out at a meeting once). If this happens and you don't have time to ensure supplier process capability, it is not the worse thing in the world, you can always blame the vendor and shop around for a new one that has no familiarity with the part and uses the same process that can't meet the specification. Sometimes the best you can do is make the risks clear.



Sunday, April 18, 2010

Finding Owners

More and more I'm learning one of the keys to making good devices that meet quality and regulatory standards is finding people who will take ownership. Lately I've been working in the packaging area a lot and almost every time I'm in there I find discarded labels without lines drawn through them. Of course these are always discarded by the other shift. Everyone already knows the labels need lined out when questioned, so the basic training is there.

If you're an owner, you walk into your area and you own it top to bottom. You don't not fix things because you weren't around. You correct the issue and take it up with the supervisor on shift change. These are the types of people you want, and why many large medical device companies pay way over what they could for manufacturing labor. Pointing out the same non conformance over and over to the same people is ridiculous.

I've been involved with contract manufacturing in China and they were excellent at following instructions. They picked up GDP about 3 times faster than anyone else and have maintained it. This is not to say everything is perfect, but the basics were taken care of. Some of the more complicated situations that came up with the contract manufacturer were really botched up before we were notified, but at least I know the easy stuff is covered.

I'm not sure that me telling the 19 year old putting labels on boxes that this is the era of global competition and she has to work smarter and harder than they are really sinks in. Hopefully, we have a chance to develop the skills necessary because you only get so many chances.



Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Labeling for Reuse of Single Use Medical Devices

Another relatively new EU requirement effective March 21, 2010 per the revised Medical Device Directive (MDD) (93/42/EEC) M5 is the following:
Where appropriate, the instructions for use must contain the following particulars:
...
If the device bears an indication that the device is for single use, information on known characteristics and technical factors known to the manufacturer that could pose a risk if the device were to be re-used. If in accordance with Section 13.1 no instructions for use are needed, the information must be made available to the user upon request;
Now it is not good enough (in the EU anyway) to just put single use device in your instructions for use (IFU), but you also must identify the risks associated with reuse (sepsis/infection is probably common). I'm sure these are already documented in your risk analysis already, just cut and paste them into your IFU. Apparently anyone already using the device off label by reusing it will be deterred by the listing of potential risks, a new mitigation is born.

This seems like a potentially slippery slope to me, why not have every warning list potential risks if not followed? Is it okay to exceed the shelf life? After all, there are no risks listed- how bad could it be? If it was really bad wouldn't they list more than just a rule like they do with reuse?

Anyway, it is not hard to comply with this requirement and we like to sell stuff in Europe, so we're in.

See my previous post on the new MDD phthalates labeling requirement.



Tuesday, May 5, 2009

Non conforming materials

Dealing with non conforming materials has become a more time consuming part of my job recently and a topic of debate within the company. The FDA has 21 CFR 820.90 on non conforming product which says:
"(a)Control of nonconforming product. Each manufacturer shall establish and maintain procedures to control product that does not conform to specified requirements. The procedures shall address the identification, documentation, evaluation, segregation, and disposition of nonconforming product. The evaluation of nonconformance shall include a determination of the need for an investigation and notification of the persons or organizations responsible for the nonconformance. The evaluation and any investigation shall be documented."
The FDA's definition of product in this case includes components and material. This has been interpreted by many as every nonconformance requires a full on investigation into the root cause and a corrective action, pictures, documentation changes and the whole deal. In fact, some have argued that each non conformance needs a CAPA that must be closed before the material can move on to the next stage. That is all fine and good unless you want to make money, lets be realistic here.

Besides, as a startup most of the corrective actions don't necessarily get too far. Lets say I get one custom cable out of 20 with a bad crimp that gives an intermittant signal. The signal is checked as it leaves the vendor, but since it was intermittant it wasn't caught. The conversation goes something like this:

Me: One of your cables had a bad crimp and the signal was intermittant.
Vendor: We're sorry, we check them 100% before they are sent out, return the cable and we will credit your account the $28 the cable cost or just recrimp it yourself.
Me: Okay.

I admit that getting after vendors isn't one of my strong points (isn't that for purchasing?), but we need these guys more than they need us- I don't want to source another vendor and then wait for their lead time to get more parts. Now if the cable is miswired or the part tolerance is too tight, then I'll fix the drawing, but our device has many parts and from time to time you're going to run into one off problems that shouldn't require huge amounts of wasted effort.

On the other end of the spectrum, I do know that the FDA will write you up if you just scrap every non conformance below a certain dollar value without explanation or investigation, so that is out of the question. So far I've been unable to convince people to include routine rework in the manufacturing process, this will be fine until nothing gets done because everything is waiting on evaluation and disposition then we will change. The best solution seems to be to link non-conformances with a risk analysis, then spend the majority of your time on the ones that could lead to patient risk or entire lots of incoming material being bad. At least that way I don't spend two hours on four dirty $2 boxes.



Sunday, April 19, 2009

Getting contract manufacturers in line

I've spent a great deal of time recently corresponding with our US based main contract manufacturer on various quality issues, mostly paperwork. These guys assemble the electronic/computer part of the device and they're used to consumer electronics assembly. Using this company is about 40% cheaper than a company that specialized in medical device electronics and was ISO 13485 certified.

We basically came along, sent them our documentation SOP and told them to follow it while doing any work for us. This didn't happen so we have a bunch of Manufacturing Process Instructions (MPIs) that don't work as device history records (DHRs) and have a few dozen errors such as scribble outs, blanks, no calibration dates, etc that don't fly in the medical device industry. So we've rewritten everything for them and trained their line on what we require and made good progress. I've learned my lesson though and will hand hold the next group through the documentation requirements.

We also ended up providing them with calibrated test setups to make it easier to track equipment used and match what we expected. Now we're ready to go though and will be making thousands of these in no time! Or maybe closer to a dozen and then make a bunch of improvements, we'll see what happens.